Man Utd news: Marcus Rashford, Alejandro Garnacho face uncertain future under Ruben Amorim

Ruben Amorim’s tenure at Manchester United received a significant boost on Sunday as the Red Devils pulled off a smash-and-grab 2-1 victory over Manchester City.

Such a statement performance over the defending champions in their own backyard came despite the Portuguese tactician dropping both Marcus Rashford and Alejandro Garnacho from the squad.

The 2-1 derby triumph stands as a testament to Amorim’s tactical flexibility but also underscores his willingness to make ruthless decisions to enforce new standards.

Sports News Blitz writer Noah Ngcobo is here with an analysis of the result.

Big names omitted for derby clash

In leaving out both Rashford and Garnacho, Amorim immediately cast doubt over their long-term futures at Old Trafford.

The bold decision to drop the two high-profile attackers from the squad was ultimately justified as Amorim’s emphasis on performance, discipline, and team standards paved the way for a memorable victory.

Ahead of the derby, Amorim had outlined his expectations for the team when stressing that everything from training effort to off-pitch conduct, including diet and team engagement, would influence selection.

Dropping Rashford and Garnacho was not explicitly labeled as a disciplinary issue, but the message was nevertheless clear: nobody is untouchable, even when it comes to the biggest fixtures.

READ MORE: Man City v Man Utd analysis: Dynamic Diallo gets Ruben Amorim’s Red Devils rocking

Last chance saloon for Rashford

Rashford’s situation appears particularly precarious. At 27, he is no longer an emerging talent but rather a senior figure expected to set an example for the rest.

Amorim’s dropping of the Mancunian reflects a deeper dissatisfaction regarding Rashford’s application in training and overall demeanour.

This situation follows previous incidents, including a couple of notable breaches under former manager Erik ten Hag, that have led some to question the talented attacker’s attitude and professionalism.

Rashford’s inconsistent form since his standout 2022-23 campaign, when he netted a brilliant 30 goals, has only intensified scrutiny.

Indeed, United’s INEOS leadership has been open to offers for Rashford since January according to reports, but his high wages and recent performances have deterred potential suitors.

Amorim’s actions now suggest that a line has been drawn: Rashford must improve on and off the pitch if he has any hopes of salvaging his place.

The forward’s post-match support for the team on social media indicates that he understands the stakes, but questions remain over his long-term future under the Portuguese.

Garnacho a work in progress

In contrast to Rashford, Garnacho faces a different kind of challenge. At just 20 years old, the Argentine still holds significant, untapped potential.

However, his tendency for visible frustration on the pitch — often in reaction to being substituted — and petulant behaviour on social media have raised serious concerns.

Garnacho’s inconsistent displays have compounded the issue, although Amorim may view this as a developmental blip rather than a definitive problem.

Unlike Rashford, then, Garnacho’s youth affords him more room for redemption.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Ruben Amorim's rotation gamble: Building Manchester United’s future amid early struggles

Demands of a new manager

Amorim’s preferred 3-4-3 formation has added further uncertainty to the pair’s roles.

In the Manchester derby, Amorim successfully deployed a front three of Mason Mount, Rasmus Højlund, and Amad Diallo.

If ever there was a sign that Garnacho and Rashford may not find a home in the new set-up, that was it.

Amad, in particular, showcased Amorim’s vision perfectly by delivering a match-winning performance and setting the correct standard for others to follow.

In the end, the new manager’s firm insistence on teamwork and tactical discipline leaves little room for players who do not meet his demands.

Pundits, it must be said, have largely supported Amorim’s decision. Both Gary Neville and Roy Keane have praised his boldness, describing it as necessary to reset the club’s culture and reinforce accountability.

Neville focused on the duo’s poor performances and lack of group engagement, while Keane emphasized that Amorim’s actions set a healthy precedent for the squad moving forward.

Risk of being left behind

For Rashford, the future looks increasingly uncertain, with many suggesting a parting of ways is inevitable unless his form and attitude change dramatically.

Garnacho is admittedly much more likely to be reintegrated, but he must adapt quickly and demonstrate a willingness to grow under Amorim’s leadership.

United’s desire to cut costs under their new ownership could also complicate matters, as both players would offer significant profit if sold.

Amorim’s tough calls are already reshaping Manchester United. The derby victory proves his approach is effective, but players must continue to meet the manager’s high standards or risk being left behind.

Rashford and Garnacho now face a pivotal period in their careers as they look to reclaim their places and prove they can be part of United’s future under Amorim.

READ NEXT: Man Utd analysis: The forwards likely to play in Ruben Amorim’s 3-4-3 formation